Many felt an apology was pointless.
Koreaboo
In late September 2023, SHINee‘s Taemin and Key got here below fireplace for feedback about Minho‘s pores and skin tone.
Within the newest SHINee.ing episode, Key and Taemin commented on Minho’s pores and skin shade, making jokes about being unable to see him at the hours of darkness and asking why he turned so tanned after spending time {golfing}.
SHINee’s Key And Taemin’s Allegedly Colorist Feedback About Minho’s Pores and skin Shade Have Followers Dissatisfied
On September 29, Key, Taemin, and SHINee’s manufacturing staff apologized for the controversial video clip, saying they took suggestions from the followers “very significantly” and could be extra cautious.
Worldwide followers and netizens had been shocked to have obtained the apologies because of SM Leisure’s monitor document in such issues.
I dont assume y’all notice how uncommon that is. What number of idols have made horrible and even worse remarks just lately and by no means apologize trigger they’ve their followers to protect themselves from accountability? The truth that SHINee apologized? Big. I’m pleased with Shawols. We aren’t a cult.
— ₛₕₐₙ · ටff (@J16328121448) September 29, 2023
shinee’s apology letter. thanks, kim kibum. thanks, lee taemin. let’s all study from this and educate ourselves the correct manner. i like you! pic.twitter.com/kohuCIQUMI
— 📂 (@shineefilms) September 29, 2023
Nevertheless, the response from Korean netizens has been completely totally different.
On a web based discussion board put up discussing the apologies, many Korean netizens had a damaging tackle the state of affairs, with many questioning why apologies had been wanted within the first place.
- No matter, sigh… It’s not a giant deal. It’s like telling somebody, “You’ve gotten such lengthy hair, you could possibly mop the ground with it.” It’s not discrimination.
- Turning this right into a manner larger deal than it’s… I’ve a black canine. I tease her on a regular basis once I take her out on a stroll at evening and I can’t see her. What’s the issue? Pffft.
- And now, Minho’s caught between a rock and a tough place. TBH, I don’t know why we would have liked apologies. And… Now that we have now them, we should always cease speaking about this altogether.
- Uh… However by no means within the historical past of “individuals with lengthy hair” all over the world did they need to undergo hell for having lengthy hair. So…
- The instances have modified. Now, you make enjoyable of darkish pores and skin, you completely should apologize.
- They teased him for having gotten sunburnt… How is that racist? Some individuals have actual psychological points to work by. They need to have a look at all the pieces as discrimination. As soon as racism’s gone, they’ll discover themselves bored as a result of they don’t have anybody to “educate.”
Whereas the response was overwhelmingly damaging, some did agree with SHINee’s must apologize.
- I’m a SHINee fan, and I feel they had been proper to apologize. It’s executed and over now.
- I’m baffled that there are individuals commenting about “Black individuals being overly delicate” and “Asians being picked on on a regular basis” when, actually, the members themselves admitted to their errors and apologized for them.
- What they stated was fairly stereotypical. So I feel they had been proper to apologize. What number of of you’d be OK with being referred to as a banana simply because “there have been sick intentions”?
- I perceive how Koreans won’t have the ability to wrap their heads round the issue. However SHINee members are international stars. They had been sensible to reply to the worldwide suggestions that shortly.
- I’m not even a SHINee fan, however I feel their apologizes had been stable. And there’s no want for any additional discussions.
On account of worldwide magnificence requirements favoring pale pores and skin, colorism occurs in lots of locations and cultures. With how deeply rooted these ideas could be, areas nonetheless battling this prejudice could not notice how dangerous saying sure issues is.
Share This Publish
